Skip to content

False Equivalences

Is Bill Maher the left-wing equivalent of Rush Limbaugh? Jon Stewart rips this meme to shreds.

I totally agree with his last line.

Share

Tribal Politics

The NY Times has an interesting article by psychologist Jonathan Haidt that examines the behavior of voters.

To understand politics, we are often told to “follow the money”. Monetary self-interest is a good predictor for the behavior of politicians, but it doesn’t seem to help at all for understanding how people vote. Consider people who who are not very rich but nonetheless support tax cuts for the wealthy (e.g., Joe the Plumber). Studies have also shown that parents whose children attend public schools are not any more supportive of government aid to schools, and people without health insurance are no more likely to favor single-payer health insurance.

In other words, ironically and despite the gospel of capitalism, people are not always selfish. Instead, we evolved to favor the interests of our group or tribe over our own interests. These groups are often built around what are considered “sacred values” — if an outsider violates one of these values, the group springs to its defense.

This happens both on the right and the left. Recent examples include the right perceiving a “War on Christianity”, while the left perceives a “War on Women”.

UPDATE: The NY Times review of Haidt’s new book about this.

Share

Late Night Political Humor

“Rush Limbaugh is losing advertisers. Crisco was one and then he lost Hostess Cupcakes. Now the only advertiser Rush has left on his radio show is Conrad Murray’s Sleep Clinic.” – David Letterman

“President Obama was at one of the games at Dayton, Ohio, tonight. He brought British Prime Minister David Cameron with him. It’s part of a cultural exchange program. They go to a basketball game here, and then in July the prime minister has invited Obama to England to take part in a soccer riot.” – Jimmy Kimmel

“Tomorrow morning President Obama is going to release his NCAA bracket. You knew this was going to happen. Republican leaders have vowed to overturn it.” – Jay Leno

“You all know Newt Gingrich. Newt is short for Newton. People say if that’s the case, what is Mitt short for? It’s short for ‘Mittens.'” – David Letterman

“Did you see Mitt Romney this week? He was trying to appeal to the Southern voters. He told folks the other day that he had a biscuit and some cheesy grits for breakfast. I didn’t know that they served that at the Ritz Carlton.” – Jay Leno

“Actually there was one awkward moment for Mitt Romney. They asked him if he’d ever been down to the banks of the Mississippi and he said, ‘No. Do they have a better rate than the Cayman Islands?'” – Jay Leno

“Osama bin Laden was living in that compound with three wives. It’s like he was Newt Gingrich.” – David Letterman

Share

Curing Corruption

The State Integrity Investigation has released the results of its study of corruption in state governments.

First, the bad news. No state received a grade of “A”, and eight states received an “F”: Michigan, North Dakota, South Carolina, Maine, Virginia, Wyoming, South Dakota, and Georgia.

Ironically, New Jersey received the highest grade (a “B+”) despite its longstanding reputation for corruption. How? The state has taken dramatic steps to enforce anti-corruption laws. “New Jersey’s strong points are clear: extensive financial disclosure requirements for the governor, a transparently-run pension fund, and an aggressive ethics enforcement agency. The state also boasts some of the nation’s toughest anti-pay-to-play laws for contractors.”

Another state with a longstanding reputation for corruption, Illinois, came in 10th place (with a “C”), also showing the results of its efforts to reduce corruption and increase transparency.

This gives me hope that there is something that can be done about official corruption, but only if public awareness is increased. You can look up a complete explanation of your state’s score on their site.

Share

Spoiled


© Tom Toles

Is anyone still actually paying attention to the Republican primary?

John McCain on Meet the Press said this presidential primary is “the nastiest I’ve ever seen” and added “it’s gone way too long and gotten way, way too personal.”

Share

Late Night Political Humor

“Here’s some very scary news: They say gasoline could be $6 a gallon. But the good news is the White House says President Obama is aware of the problem, and will continue to talk about it between fundraisers.” – Jay Leno

“President Obama today released his NCAA bracket. He is a huge basketball fan. But privately, White House aides are worried that if he spends so much time on this, it could affect his golf game.” – Jay Leno

“Happy birthday to Mitt Romney, he’s 65 years old. At his party, he didn’t blow out the candles. He gave a speech and the candles just flickered and died.” – Jay Leno

“Romney’s birthday is not a big deal here. But in the Cayman Islands, it’s a national holiday.” – Jay Leno

‎”If you are a multi-millionaire entertainer supporting the candidacy of a wealthy financier from Massachusetts, you might no longer be a redneck.” – Stephen Colbert on Jeff Foxworthy campaigning with Mitt Romney

“I’m telling you, it’s getting ugly on the campaign trail. Rick Santorum’s people are accusing Mitt Romney’s campaign of trying to dig up dirt on Ron Paul. He must be an archaeologist.” – Jay Leno

“Rick Santorum insists he’s the most conservative candidate. He is so conservative, you can only rub him the wrong way.” – Jay Leno

“Rick Santorum is so conservative; he thinks KY Jelly is jam made in Kentucky.” – Jay Leno

“How about that Rush Limbaugh? It was nice for me to see somebody else apologizing for something for a change.” – David Letterman

“Don’t kid yourself, Rush is in a lot of trouble. He’s down to two national sponsors. You know what they are? One is Crisco, and the other is Hostess Twinkies.” – David Letterman

Share

We’re Here to Help!


© Ruben Bolling

People are outraged that the president has assumed the authority to assassinate anyone he determines to be a terrorist, without judicial review or congressional oversight, and even if the target is an American citizen. But the constitution does give the president the power to prosecute wars, and wars do involve killing people. The problem I have is that Congress has declared war on terror, whatever the hell that means. Will this war continue until we — as Bolling says — sign a peace treaty with the Concept of Terrorism? Or has 1984 finally come true and we are now in a state of perpetual war?

Share

The Root of All Evil

CBS smuggled secret cameras into a weekend-long fundraiser for twelve freshman Republican Congressmen, held at an exclusive resort in Florida and attended by lobbyists and special interests, who each paid a minimum of $10,000 and as much as $46,200 (the legal maximum) to attend.

The CBS article points out the hypocrisy of the event, using quotes from these Congressmen taken from their 2010 election campaigns promising to change the way Washington works and (as one put it) put “families before the Washington special interests”.

But somehow I can’t blame these guys. The lesson isn’t that these guys are corrupt and we should replace them with someone new who won’t be beholden to special interests. Because that’s exactly what we keep doing, with increasingly predictable results. Even Obama promised “change”, and while I will give him credit for actually trying to change things, he hasn’t changed them nearly enough.

Instead, we need to fix Washington’s dependence on money, in particular, money from special interests. As I’ve said before, I think a good first step is to pass laws requiring transparency. CBS shouldn’t have to sneak cameras into these events. They should be public. It should be public record whenever an elected official spends time with someone who also donates campaign money.

Share

Late Night Political Humor

“Rick Santorum has come out against contraception and against college. He wants us literally to be fucking stupid.” – Bill Maher

“Rick Santorum nearly won Ohio, despite a flood of ads that said that Rick Santorum is a creepy, far-right, socially backward extremist – and those were his ads. That’s how he sells himself.” – Bill Maher

“Rick Santorum today won the Kansas caucuses beating Mitt Romney by 30 percent. Santorum was expected to do well in Kansas because it’s also a giant square.” – Seth Meyers

“Mitt Romney won a key victory in the Ohio Super Tuesday primary narrowly beating Rick Santorum by just 1 percent. Specifically, the 1 percent.” – Seth Meyers

“Romney is not a regular guy. He was campaigning in Mississippi this week and said ‘some of my best friends spill oil in this gulf.’” – Bill Maher

“Here’s an actual quote. Romney was in Mississippi yesterday, and he said, ‘I’m learning to say y’all, and I like grits.’ And then he took out a pair of pliers and yanked out three of his teeth.” – Bill Maher

“Poor Mitt Romney. He can’t get the hang of campaigning like a regular guy. He’s always remind people of his vast wealth. Today he demanded to see Obama’s gift certificate.” – Bill Maher

“In the south, Mitt is going to have trouble with the whole Mormon thing. When he says sister wife down there, it means a whole different thing.” – Bill Maher

“That Mitt Romney, he is a master campaigner. This week he was introducing his wife, and he said, ‘She is the heavyweight champion of my life.” Which may explain why on the ride home, he was strapped to the roof of the car.” – Bill Maher

“To recap the Republican views on women: you can’t have birth control, you’re sluts, and you’re fat. Vote for me in November everyone.” – Bill Maher

“Don’t pay eight thousand dollars for a McNugget that looks like George Washington. At least until you have Sarah Palin authenticate it. She could tell you if it really resembles the father of our country, the man who won the war on Christmas, crossed the Danube, signed the Declaration of Constitution, and accepted the surrender of Cornwallis at Funkytown. Newt Gingrich is a historian too, but don’t show it to him or he’ll just eat it.” – Bill Maher

“Despite only winning the Super Tuesday primary in Georgia, Newt Gingrich vowed to continue his campaign, saying ‘I’m the tortoise. I take it one step at a time. Also, if you roll me onto my back I can never get up.’” – Seth Meyers

“Rush Limbaugh has lost so many advertisers that on Thursday there was five minutes on his show of dead air. And most observers agree he’s never been so eloquent.” – Bill Maher

“Just for shits and giggles, John McCain must make a speech on the Senate floor where he calls on America to not bomb someone. This week, John McCain said we needed to bomb Syria. Because he’s John McCain. And it’s a country. Duh. John McCain thinks countries need bombing like your waiter thinks food needs fresh pepper. Remember how we let John Glenn go back into space when he was 77? We should let John McCain fly one more airstrike. He’s only 75. Let him do it. Then, when he crashes, we can send John Glenn to rescue him, and Ed Harris can play them both in the movie.” – Bill Maher

Share

The Elephant in the Room


© Lee Judge

Share

It Takes Two To Tango

[Politicians who are shaming and blaming woman for having sex are forgetting something. Written by Emily L. Hauser, reprinted from her blog “In My Head“]

Dear GOP: You do know how pregnancy works, right?

I have been pregnant four times.

These pregnancies led to the following four results, in this order: abortion, baby, miscarriage, baby.

These pregnancies occurred over a span of many years, across two continents, and in three different homes. There were at least seven different health care professionals involved, my hair styles varied widely, as did my levels of nausea. The only constant, in all four cases, other than me, was the presence of a penis.

It happened to be the penis I eventually married, but regardless, that is how pregnancy works. No matter who you are, no matter your sexuality, ability to reproduce, or family make-up, if there are children in your life, at some point along the way, there was a penis involved.

I mention this only because it seems the GOP may have forgotten.

Because as we trundle along, shaming women for having any kind of sex, ever, that is not entirely focused on producing babies — even if we are married, even if it wasn’t so much “sex” as “rape,” even if having a baby would threaten our health and thus the well-being of the children we already have — we are completely and utterly ignoring the fact that the single, solitary way for humans to reproduce is for sperm to meet egg. And sperm, you may recall, come from penises.

Which are attached to men.

If women are having too much sex, so are men. If women are producing babies, so are men. If women are making irresponsible reproductive choices with which they want to burden “the American people” — so.are.men.

Birth control, abortions, prenatal care, postpartum care, child care — whatever we may think, whatever we may have been told — are not women’s issues. THEY ARE HUMAN ISSUES.

There is a purely incandescent rage that comes over me now on a nearly daily basis over the blatant dehumanization of women that is currently sweeping the nation. It is exhausting. It is heart breaking. It is spirit crushing. And there’s nothing to be done but to continue to feel it, because I refuse to stop fighting for my right, my daughter’s right, my mother’s right, my sister’s right — the inalienable right of all women everywhere — to human dignity.

But every once and a while, a particularly galling aspect of the GOP’s War on Women floats to the top of the filth, and I am gobsmacked anew. And today it is as simple as this: Women do not reproduce on their own.

If the Republican Party is so anxious to control women’s sexuality (and it clearly is), it had better start shaming men, too.

That is, unless its representatives are willing to argue that men are constitutionally incapable of not sticking their junk into the nearest available lady bits, and we gals have all the power.

I, for one, have too much respect for men to buy that.

Share

Slime ‘Em!


© Jen Sorensen

Commentary by Jen Sorensen:

I spent way too much time last weekend reading about pink slime. I really wanted to get to the bottom of the slimebucket, if you will. This particular controversy has been burbling (and oozing and gurgling) ever since celebrity chef Jamie Oliver did a segment trashing the stuff last year (it’s a little melodramatic, but the basic sentiment is sound). McDonald’s, Taco Bell, and Burger King proceeded to drop it from their beef. More recently, a couple microbiologists condemned the goop as nutritionally-deficient, woefully-unlabeled Not Meat.

Now, I’ve traveled enough and watched enough cable-network food shows to know that gross-seeming animal parts are edible, and possibly even a delicacy, depending on the palate of the beholder. So I wanted to mentally separate the unappetizing aspect of pink slime from the food safety/nutrition issues. Here’s what I’ve discerned:

There’s a case to be made that ammoniated meat is safer because pathogens are reduced. But at the high levels of ammonia that may be required to effectively kill bacteria, the meat starts to reek of ammonia. The Times has a lengthy report on the iffy history of this particular technology. This Prevention article also raises some good questions about what we don’t know.

Personally, I don’t want to be a human guinea pig for ammonia ingestion. It seems intuitive that schoolkids shouldn’t be, either. The fact that they have to use ammonia in the first place is a symptom of the larger problem of industrial meat production. That these scraps are teeming with deadly bacteria in the first place is a result of the appalling conditions in feedlots (or CAFOs). The meat industry, in defense of pink slime, laughably touts the “sustainability” of using all parts of the cow, as though these people give one whit about environmentally-friendly farming practices. And then there’s the fact that the stuff is just low-quality, non-nutritious crap, the logical endpoint of a system built on layers and layers of crap. Is this really the best we can do for our kids?

Share

Late Night Political Humor

“The latest polls show President Obama’s approval rating among women has risen by 10 percent. Many people believe this increase is due to Obama’s new campaign slogan: ‘Tell me about your day.’” – Conan O’Brien

“In a few months Obama’s going to unveil this one: ‘Would you like white wine and a foot massage?’” – Conan O’Brien

“It was reported that in the weeks leading up to his death, Osama bin Laden had trouble controlling the squabbling among his three wives. In fact, when the team knocked down the door, bin Laden said, ‘Thank god you’re here. Two in the chest. One in the head. Let’s do this.’” – Conan O’Brien

“Stoners just got a powerful new ally in the fight to legalize marijuana — conservative broadcaster Pat Robertson. He said it’s time to ‘you know, legalize it, tax it, and keep it away from Mel Gibson.’” – Craig Ferguson

“I don’t see why anyone is surprised, though. Pat Robertson is 81 years old. After a certain point, old people don’t care what anybody thinks. They just don’t. They wear socks with sandals.” – Craig Ferguson

“Robertson said he never smoked pot and never will, and that just because something is ‘legal’ doesn’t mean we should do it. That’s the argument I always use against pineapple on your pizza.” – Craig Ferguson

“A phone survey found 70 percent of Americans support legalizing marijuana. I can’t believe that many marijuana supporters managed to answer the phone.” – Craig Ferguson

“This week a Chicken McNugget that resembles President George Washington was auctioned on eBay for over $8,000. Meanwhile, a Chicken McNugget that looks like Mitt Romney was eaten by Newt Gingrich.” – Conan O’Brien

Share

The Bankruptcy of Opposing the Individual Mandate

Somehow, you knew this was going to happen.

The woman who owns a small auto repair shop and is now the lead plaintiff in the case going to the Supreme Court to overturn Obama’s health care reform because she claims she should not be required to have health insurance, has filed for bankruptcy with a bunch of unpaid medical bills.

In other words, she is “an example of exactly the problem that the healthcare law was intended to address”. Her bankruptcy is one of the millions that will raise the cost of health care for all of us. According to a health law expert “This is so ironic. It just shows that all Americans inevitably have a need for healthcare. Somebody has paid for her healthcare costs. And she is now among the 62% whose personal bankruptcy was attributable in part to medical bills.”

And to make this a bit hypocritical, after the failure of her business she is now supported by unemployment compensation, which is opposed by the same people who want to kill health care reform. So much for personal responsibility.

Share

The Wages of Greed

The financial world is in a tizzy about an editorial published yesterday in the NY Times written by an executive of Goldman Sachs (who simultaneously tendered his resignation). It doesn’t paint a very pretty picture of the company.

Ironically, the reaction from both supporters and detractors of Goldman Sachs is pretty much the same — “are you surprised that Goldman Sachs gleefully screws over their clients to further their goal of making as much money as possible, by any means?” Detractors because none of this is news — a Senate investigation and recent convictions for fraud said the same thing. Supporters of Goldman Sachs because they think that screwing over clients and rampant greed are normal and acceptable, so what’s the fuss all about?

Meanwhile, the value of Goldman’s stock dropped by over $2 billion on the news.

Wouldn’t it be really ironic if the author of the editorial shorted Goldman’s stock just before his piece was published, thus making lots of money at Goldman’s expense the same way that Goldman makes money at their clients’ expense?

Share